1 / 7Rothy's The Square Mary Jane Women's Knit Flat
Rothy's The Square Mary Jane is a women's knit flat described in the listing. Customer feedback highlights comfort and dress-to-casual versatility, alongside mixed reports about fit and durability, so sizing and long-term wear may matter to your decision.
At a glance
- Women's knit flat with a Mary Jane design, as named in the listing.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Customers report comfort and soft cushioning, and some say the flexible material accommodates wider toe areas.
- Feedback describes the style as suitable for both dress and casual wear.
Technical specifications
2 specifications| Brand | Rothy's |
|---|---|
| Department | womens |
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Shoppers looking for a women's knit Mary Jane flat for dress and casual outfits.
- Buyers who prioritize comfort and appreciate customer reports of flexible fit around the toe area.
Less suited to
- Shoppers who need confidently predictable sizing or established durability, since customer feedback includes mixed experiences on both.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
67% 67% - 4 stars
11% 11% - 3 stars
10% 10% - 2 stars
4% 4% - 1 star
8% 8%
Customer feedback highlights comfort, soft cushioning, appearance, washability, and use with both dress and casual outfits. Fit and value experiences are mixed, with some sizing issues and durability concerns also reported. These perceptions may help set expectations, but the listing provides no detailed sizing or durability specifications to resolve those concerns.
Positive themes
- Customers describe the shoes as comfortable, chic, washable, and versatile for dress and casual wear.
- Some feedback notes soft cushioning and flexible material that accommodates wider toe areas.
Negative themes
- Some customers report sizing issues.
- Some customers raise durability concerns.
Mixed feedback
- Feedback on fit and value for money is mixed.
Frequently asked questions
What kind of shoe is The Square Mary Jane?
The listing identifies it as a women's knit flat with a Mary Jane style.
What do customers say about comfort?
Feedback highlights comfort and soft cushioning, with one report noting that the flexible material accommodates wider toe areas.
Are fit and durability consistently praised?
No. Customer feedback includes sizing issues and durability concerns, so experiences are mixed.

Alternative options

Rothy's The Casual Clog, Women's Slip-On Mule Shoe | Platform Shoe with Cushioned Comfort Insole, Sustainable & Machine-Washable, All-Day Wear, Made with Recycled Plastic Bottles
$109.00

Rothy's The Almond Slingback, New Women's Flats | Closed-Toe & Back Strap for All-Day Wear, Sustainable & Machine Washable, Made with Recycled Plastic Bottles
$89.00

Women's Pointed Toe Rhinestone Ballet Flats, Suede Comfortable Slip On Dress Shoes ...
$22.60

XMM Mary Jane Shoes Women Platform Chunky Cute Teen Girls Dress School Flat | Ladies Mary Janes for Women Comfortable Round Toe Ankle Strap Non-Slip Dressy Work Casual Fall Uniform Cosplay Flats
$35.91

Women's Knit Flats with Memory Foam Slip on Pointed Toe Work Shoes | Ballet Flat,Ve...
$18.49

Women's Mary Jane Pumps Double Strap Block Heel Dress Wedding Party Shoes | Closed ...
$23.79

VIVAIA Jovin Women's Mary Jane Flats, Square Toe Washable Knit Adjustable Strap
$139.00

Rothy's The Women's Daily Loafer, Slip-On Shoes for Women | Cushioned Arch Support for All-Day Wear, Sustainable & Machine Washable, Made with Recycled Plastic Bottles
$135.00

Rothy's The Point II, Women's Slip-On Ballet Flat | Pointed-Toe, Cushioned Insole, Sustainable & Machine Washable, Made with Recycled Plastic Bottles
$99.00

Loeffler Randall Women's Franco Boat Shoes
$325.00

Square Toe Mary Jane Flats for Women Dressy Comfortable Knit Ballet Flat Adjustable...
$32.99

Women's Mary Jane Square Toe Lightweight Knit Ballet Flats | Breathable, Slip-resis...
$29.99






















