Good Deal PicksDeals for the United States
BlogSearch
Product guide

Rothy's The Square Mary Jane Women's Knit Flat

Rothy's The Square Mary Jane is a women's knit flat with a square-toe Mary Jane silhouette. Customer feedback points to comfort and versatile styling, but fit and durability experiences are mixed, so sizing and expected wear matter when deciding.

At a glance

  • The listing identifies a women's knit flat in a square-toe Mary Jane style.
  • Customer feedback mentions comfort, soft cushioning, washability and use with both dressy and casual outfits.
  • Feedback also includes sizing and durability concerns.
Price
$89.00Save 44%

Reference price: $159.00

Price checked: Nov 19, 2026

View offer

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Customers report comfort and soft cushioning, with flexible material said to accommodate wide toe areas.
  • Reported versatility across dressy and casual outfits may suit buyers seeking one flat for different settings.
  • Washability is a reported positive.

Technical specifications

2 specifications
Identity
BrandRothy's
Departmentwomens

Who is it for?

A good fit for

  • Shoppers looking for a women's knit Mary Jane flat with a square toe.
  • Buyers who value reported comfort, cushioning and versatility for dressy and casual wear.
  • Those willing to weigh mixed sizing and durability feedback before choosing.

Less suited to

  • Buyers who need predictable sizing or confirmed long-term durability based on the available feedback.
Rothy's The Square Mary Jane Women's Knit Flat · photo 2
Additional product photo 2

Customer reviews on Amazon

4.2 / 5 · 291 ratings
  • 5 stars67%67%
  • 4 stars11%11%
  • 3 stars10%10%
  • 2 stars4%4%
  • 1 star8%8%

Customer feedback highlights comfort, appearance, versatility, washability and soft cushioning. Some customers describe flexible material that accommodates wider toe areas, while others report sizing and durability concerns, and opinions on value are mixed. This may suit buyers seeking a comfortable knit flat for varied outfits, but fit and wear expectations remain important considerations.

Positive themes

  • Customers report comfort and soft cushioning.
  • Customers praise the appearance and versatility for dressy and casual wear.
  • Washability is noted positively.

Negative themes

  • Some customers report durability concerns.

Mixed feedback

  • Fit experiences are mixed, including sizing issues.
  • Opinions on value for money are mixed.

Frequently asked questions

What kind of shoe is The Square Mary Jane?

The listing identifies it as a women's knit flat in a square-toe Mary Jane style.

What do customers report about comfort and fit?

Feedback often highlights comfort and soft cushioning, while sizing experiences are mixed. Consider fit carefully when choosing.

Is it suitable for both dressy and casual wear?

Customers report wearing it for both dressy and casual outfits.

What concerns appear in customer feedback?

Some customers report sizing issues and durability concerns, alongside positive feedback about comfort and washability.

Rothy's The Square Mary Jane Women's Knit Flat · photo 3
Additional product photo 3

Alternative options

Products with discounts that might interest you

4.4
Zigzagger Loafer Men’s Moccasin Slippers with Memory Foam
Zigzagger Loafer Men’s Moccasin Slippers with Memory Foam

$36.99

$29.59

-20%
-20%
Product details in Markdown