Good Deal PicksDeals for the United States
BlogSearch
Product guide

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane Women’s Knit Flat

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane is a women’s knit flat with a Mary Jane profile and square-toe styling. Customer feedback reports comfort and versatility for dressed-up and casual wear, while fit and durability receive mixed reports.

At a glance

  • Knit Mary Jane flat with square-toe styling, as identified in the product title.
  • Customer feedback mentions soft cushioning, washability and wear with both dressy and casual outfits.
Price
$89.00Save 44%

Reference price: $159.00

Price checked: Nov 19, 2026

View offer

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Customers report comfort and flexible material, including accommodation around wider toe areas.
  • Reported versatility for dress and casual wear may suit buyers looking for one flat for different outfits.
  • Customer feedback also describes the shoes as chic and washable.

Technical specifications

2 specifications
Identity
BrandRothy's
Departmentwomens

What to know before buying

  • Sizing and durability receive mixed customer reports, so consider fit carefully and do not assume long-term wear will meet every buyer’s expectations. The listing provides no specific care instructions.

Who is it for?

A good fit for

  • Shoppers seeking a knit Mary Jane flat for dressy and casual outfits.
  • Buyers who prioritize reported comfort and flexible fit around the toe area.

Less suited to

  • Shoppers who need assured sizing or durability, since customer feedback is mixed on both.
Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane Women’s Knit Flat · photo 2
Additional product photo 2

Customer reviews on Amazon

4.2 / 5 · 292 ratings
  • 5 stars68%68%
  • 4 stars11%11%
  • 3 stars9%9%
  • 2 stars4%4%
  • 1 star8%8%

Customer feedback highlights comfort, appearance, versatility, washability and soft cushioning, with some reporting flexible material that accommodates wider toe areas. Others report sizing and durability concerns, and opinions on value are mixed. For buyers choosing a knit flat for varied outfits, those reported comforts may matter, but the feedback does not establish consistent fit or long-term durability. Overall ratings lean positive, though a meaningful minority of ratings are lower.

Positive themes

  • Customers report comfort and soft cushioning.
  • Customers describe the shoes as chic and versatile for dress and casual wear.
  • Some customers appreciate the washable shoe and flexible material.

Negative themes

  • Some customers report sizing issues.
  • Some customers report durability concerns.

Mixed feedback

  • Customer views on value for money are mixed.
  • Fit feedback is mixed, despite reports of flexible material.

Frequently asked questions

What type of shoe is The Square Mary Jane?

The listing identifies it as a women’s knit flat in a Mary Jane style with square-toe styling.

What do customers report about comfort and fit?

Customer feedback highlights comfort and flexible material, including accommodation around wider toe areas. Fit reports are mixed, so the feedback does not establish a consistent fit for every wearer.

What concerns appear in customer feedback?

Some customers report sizing issues and durability concerns. These are reported experiences, not a confirmed defect or a guarantee of how an individual pair will perform.

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane Women’s Knit Flat · photo 3
Additional product photo 3

Alternative options

Products with discounts that might interest you

4.0
Project Cloud Becker Genuine Leather Penny Loafer Mules
Project Cloud Becker Genuine Leather Penny Loafer Mules

$79.99

$59.90

-25%
-25%
Product details in Markdown